Main Number: (575) 523-1100
PO BOX 816
Las Cruces, NM 88004
M-F: 8AM – 5PM
McGonigle Insurance is a locally owned, family operated independent agency dedicated to fulfilling the risk management & insurance needs of residents and businesses in New Mexico and Texas by providing the best insurance services and products. With over 50 years of combined staff experience, we know how to take care of your insurance needs. Providing you with the best coverage at the best value is what we strive to achieve.
The McGonigle Insurance Story started back in 1953, when William “Bill” McGonigle started in the insurance industry as a claims adjuster for GMAC. In 1956, Bill started working for Allstate as an agent. Bill had the first successful Allstate office in Las Cruces, NM, which was located on Telshor Blvd. Bill’s sons, Bill & Bob McGonigle started to work at the office in 1983 & 1988 respectively. Bob McGonigle left Allstate in 1990 to become an Independent Insurance Agent. In 2002, Bob purchased the Rio Valley Insurance Agency and became a Brooke Insurance Franchisee. In late 2008, the agency broke away from Brooke and became McGonigle Insurance.